LS | Lisa Stern
Virtual Consultations Available | 248-973-7842
  • Home
  • About
    • Lisa D. Stern
  • Practice Areas
    • Divorce
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Second Family Adoption
    • Red Flag Laws
  • Blog
  • Articles
  • Contact
LS | Lisa Stern
  • Home
  • About
    • Lisa D. Stern
  • Practice Areas
    • Divorce
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Second Family Adoption
    • Red Flag Laws
  • Blog
  • Articles
  • Contact
Email

CALL

Lisa D. Stern

Over 30 YearsOf Serving Families In Michigan

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. parental rights
  4.  » 
  5. Court grants parental rights to lesbian egg donor

Court grants parental rights to lesbian egg donor

On Behalf of Lisa D. Stern | Nov 8, 2013 | parental rights |

In a move that could have far-reaching effects and establish legal precedents in Michigan and other states, a state Supreme Court ruled in favor of a woman who donated an egg cell which was used to artificially inseminate her partner, with the two women separating after the child’s birth. There was disagreement on whether state laws prohibit anonymous egg or sperm donors from claiming child custody or parental rights. The court was divided, but ultimately handed down a 4-3 ruling.

The court’s majority opinion found that preventing the donor from interacting with and helping to care for the child would effectively violate the woman’s constitutionally guaranteed rights of equal protection and due process. It continued to explain that the donor adequately showed dedication to caring for her child.

The three dissenting Justices countered the majority using a similar argument. The Justice who penned the opinion asserted that giving the donor parental rights would constitute a violation of the other woman’s rights to privacy and due process.

The dissenting Justices noted that a child’s birth mother is typically granted automatic parental rights. The opinion continued to argue that the ruling does not preclude the donor from having her own child in the future and thus does not violate any parental privileges, though court documents suggest the donor could have been impregnated with the egg cell because she was infertile.

The donor’s case was supported by briefs from Lambda Legal, the American Civil Liberties Union and other organizations.

While this dispute occurred outside of Michigan, it serves as a potent reminder of how complex the law can be, especially regarding the increasing prevalence of same sex couples marrying and raising children. This makes it crucial for one preparing for such a dispute to have sophisticated knowledge of their states’ court systems.

Source:  Orlando Sentinel, “Lesbian egg donor in Brevard parental-rights dispute gets support from Florida high court” Jim Saunders, Nov. 08, 2013

Recent Posts

  • What happens to deferred compensation during a divorce?
  • What Do I Do If My Ex Stops Paying Child Support?
  • Is There An Advantage To Filing For Divorce First In Michigan?
  • How To Get Sole Custody In Michigan
  • Do You Still Pay Child Support With 50/50 Custody?

Archives

Categories

  • Adoption
  • Child Custody
  • Child Support
  • Divorce
  • Fathers' Rights
  • Firm News
  • modifications
  • parental relocation
  • parental rights
  • Same-sex Marriage
  • Uncategorized
  • Visitation

RSS Feed

Subscribe To This Blog’s Feed

The Experience You Need. The Compassion You Deserve.

Contact Lisa For Help Today

LS | Lisa Stern

Bloomfield Hills Office

1760 South Telegraph Road
Suite 300
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302


Bloomfield Hills law office

Detroit Office

Penobscot Building
645 Griswold St.

Suite 2200
Detroit, MI 48226



Detroit law office

Phone Number

248-973-7842
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
Review The Firm

© 2025 Lisa D. Stern • All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw

Review The Firm